Showing posts with label costs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label costs. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

The cost of justice ...

A recent decision in the Nova Scotia Supreme Court highlights the problems with the current justice system.

In Fougere v. Enfield Hardware the defendant homeowners had a cottage that they wanted the plaintiff builder to renovate into a retirement home. The parties entered into a contract in September 2001. The contract price was $121,000. The defendants occupied the house in June 2002. By this time they had paid all the contract price save for a holdback of $14,000. They complained of numerous deficiencies, and refused to pay the balance.

The builder sued for the holdback. The homeowners counterclaimed for the cost of various deficiencies and damages.

The action went to trial in April 2006, four years after the defendants occupied the house. The trial took 9 days and was spread over a year, with the last day in April 2007. The decision was delivered in February 2009.

The result? The judge found that the defendants had established $7,000 worth of deficiencies, which he deducted from the holdback of $14,000. The balance of the holdback was ordered to be paid to the plaintiff. He also dismissed the balance of the defendants' counterclaim.

So, an action for a holdback of $14,000, which is well within the $25,000 jurisdiction of the Nova Scotia Small Claims Court, ended up taking almost 7 years (and 9 days of trial) to get a result that saw one party ordered to pay roughly $7,000 to the other. One shudders to think of the cost, both in money, time and emotion, that was spent by the parties to reach such a resolution of their dispute.

Such a result cannot be right. Nor can the blame for such a mismatch between cost (in time and money) and result be laid at the door of the parties. Surely the justice system has an obligation to develop procedures that would offer a quicker and cheaper resolution to such disputes.

Saturday, February 21, 2009

Following the wrong path ...

Arbitrations are often conducted by lawyers (both as advocates and as arbitrators). As a result there can be a tendency on the part of the players to replicate rather than avoid the formalities of the traditional legal system. The tendency must be resisted if it is not to eviscerate the benefits of ADR.

A recent case out of Ontario demonstrates what can go wrong if arbitrators and advocates are not more cautious about transferring court-like procedures into the arbitration process. In Van Kempen v. Brown Pineo Insurance Brokers Ltd a dispute arose between an employer and an employee. The employee considered himself dismissed in December 2003. Arbitration proceedings (pursuant to the employment agreement) were commenced. After a 23-day hearing the arbitrator released decisions on various aspects of the dispute in February and April 2008. Damages of $285,500 were awarded to the employer together with costs of $355,800.

The history of this case raises a question and a concern. First, why did it take more than four years to get to a hearing (or at least a decision), and why did the hearing take so long? Was it because the lawyers and the arbitrator chose the "traditional" approach of the courts to evidence and procedure? If so, wouldn't that defeat one of the ends of the arbitration process, which is to substitute more flexible (hence less expensive and quicker) procedures for those of the courts?

Second, the fact that the costs (which had been awarded on a full indemnity basis because of the losing party's failure to accept some offers to settle) were so high--higher than the damages awarded--raises the possibility that "ordinary" people will be reluctant to try arbitration because of the fear of the consequences. Which means that deep-pocked litigants will be able to "scare" impecunious opponents to give up otherwise meritorious claims or defences.

When that happens in the courts we become justly concerned about the resulting denial of access to justice. What then do we say when it happens in the field of arbitration--a field that at least in part was fashioned to address the problem that people couldn't afford to access justice through the court system.

Friday, January 30, 2009

The cost of accessing justice ...

There was an troubling article in today's Globe and Mail by Gary Mason about the high fees that parties must pay to the BC Supreme Court for the right to have a jury trial. The case in question would have had the plaintiffs paying about $15,000 in "rent" for the courthouse and another $25,000 for jury fees. The fees proved too much for the plaintiff, who was forced to abandon her trial.

The cost of the justice system is something that is paid for by all our taxes. Adding substantial user fees erects a barrier to justice. If people cannot afford to access the system, can one say that there is equal justice for all? I note that when this issue came up in Nova Scotia the court struck down similar court hearing fees as violating the public's Charter right to access the courts: see Pleau v Nova Scotia (Prothonotary) 1998 CanLII 12462 (NSSC).

Cases like the one discussed by Mr Mason highlight the system's need to address the increasingly high barriers to access to our courts being erected by user fees, party-and-party costs and solicitors's fees.